Saturday November 29 2014
Ronaldo deserves the Ballon d’Or

The Ballon d’Or has lost its appeal. Misconstrued as a popularity contest and lost in controversy, Mina Rzouki asks why Cristiano Ronaldo isn’t everyone’s choice?

In 2010, France Football’s Ballon d’Or and the FIFA World Player of the Year award merged to create one trophy, the ultimate trophy for the individual to win within a collective game. The first to emerge victorious was Lionel Messi in 2010 leaving the world perplexed. Was he the most talented player? Certainly, but did he deserve to win then award in a year Wesley Sneijder won the treble with Inter and led Netherlands to the final of the World Cup? Absolutely not.

According to Michel Platini, a Spaniard ought to have triumphed as they had won the World Cup. One can understand his reasoning but while Andres Iniesta dazzled and Xavi Hernandez pulled the strings, there was no one player who did more for his teams than Sneijder and yet the playmaker did not even make the final three-man shortlist.

For many, the award lost all meaning when Diego Milito, the Argentine who scored the winning goal in the Champions League final, Coppa Italia final and Serie A match to ensure Inter’s treble wasn’t even included in the 23-man short list. Newspapers and blogs dubbed the decision comical, a farce and immediately, the trophy lost its prestige.

“The Ballon d'Or is no longer for the best player. It's all about politics,” remarked Franck Ribery. The Frenchman’s continued comments surrounding the trophy suggest he’s yet to overcome the bitterness at not winning the coveted prize last season but did he deserve it? Perhaps, simply because his team won the treble in a year his rivals accomplished less with their respective sides.

However, while politics may have played a part in the voting process, Ribery must also recognise that the beauty of his Bayern Munich side lied in its collective power. There was no individual who stood out simply because it was the combination of the players’ skills and their willingness to sacrifice that led to such triumph. It was Manuel Neuer’s saves, Philipp Lahm’s leadership and Arjen Robben’s goals than ensured the team’s progression in Europe, not to mention his man of the match performance in the final.

Ronaldo went on to win the prize in 2014 and for him, it meant the world. Each year he betters his performances in order to win everything and yet he always seems to be the player others feel isn’t deserving. Rarely does Messi get attacked but when Ronaldo is the favourite then Neuer feels justified to poke fun at underwear commercials and ‘living the red carpet lifestyle’.

This season, the three players that will most likely shortlisted to win the trophy are Ronaldo, Messi and Manuel Neuer. Messi may have helped his side to the World Cup final but Neuer won the World Cup and Ronaldo lifted the Champions League, the long awaited Decima.

There is no doubting Neuer’s skills and the impact he had on Germany in the World Cup, whether it be by making outstanding saves or playing with his feet. However, Casillas too managed extraordinary performances for Spain in 2010 - in fact it was his one-on-one save against Robben in the final than ensured victory - whilst we can never forget the penalty save on Oscar Cardozo.

Unfortunately for the Bayern Munich goalkeeper, Ronaldo still did more this year. He won the Golden Shoe, was top scorer in both the League and the Champions League and recently broke a record when he became the first player to score against every team he has played against in Spain's top flight.

Combined with his defensive contributions due to his aerial ability and the manner in which he has improved his overall attacking play, helping to create space for his teammates as well as providing assists, Ronaldo is the player who makes an impact in every single game he plays. How can he not win the award?

Have your say...
Neuer is a good goalkeeper,but at times he take useless risks with his feet putting his team in danger.
This also should be considered. Messi i cannot see why he is on this shortlist last season he was shit. Ronaldo had a peferct season. James Rodriguez was the best player of worlcup,not messi.Robben,suarez and Sergio Ramos could have been on this 3-man list in the place of messi. So i think it will be between Neuer and Ronaldo, but Ronaldo has a huge advantage,he won almost everything last year
on the 3rd December, 2014 at 4:25pm
Ronaldo deserves the Ballon d’Or
because he has been scoring more than the games he have play.
Ronaldo scored 71 goals in the campions leqgue.
top score in the la liga. the top score all time in portugal.
i say Ronaldo deserves the Ballon d’Or
tis not easy to score like Ronaldo
on the 1st December, 2014 at 11:38am
The argument that he scored against every top flight team in La Liga is bogus argument for giving Ronaldo the Ballon d’Or. Secondly, you talked about winning the Golden Ball, so should the Ballon d’Or be given to Luiz Suarez, he was a joint scorer as well. People should not be campaigning for the Ballon d’Or
on the 29th November, 2014 at 11:39pm
Looking beyond the goals, you can't believe he's even a candidate. Disappeared in every big game this year, including final stage of Champions League. Wasn't among the top-5 Madrid players in semis and final. And lol at defensive contribution and providing assists...
on the 29th November, 2014 at 7:15pm

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Espana before appearing on the site. Your data may be made public and you accept our Privacy Policy. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.
Football Italia website