Sunday December 23 2012
My Golden Nominee - Cristiano Ronaldo

Cristiano Ronaldo doesn’t deserve to emerge from one of the game’s greatest ever rivalries with nothing to show for it, argues Scott Fleming.

If you search hard enough, you can find footage on YouTube of Rio Ferdinand, Anderson and Cristiano Ronaldo - still a Manchester United player at the time - being interviewed at a film premiere. When asked who the greatest player of all time is, Ferdinand and Anderson both say Diego Maradona. Then the microphone is turned towards Ronaldo. “Me,” he deadpans, before stumbling away giggling.

A trivial incident, from long ago, but one that helps to explain the uniformity of opinion when it comes to the great debate of our times - Ronaldo or Messi?

Whereas Lionel Messi is always at pains to credit teammates for his individual accomplishments, Ronaldo worships at his own altar. He probably spends the same amount of time on his hair before a game, as Messi does in an entire year. Whereas the Barcelona man has a quiet and stable home life with his wife Antonella and new son Thiago, his Real Madrid rival prefers a rotation of supermodel girlfriends plus a son born in mysterious circumstances - let’s not rule out the possibility of cloning - and named after himself.

None of this should come into the equation when evaluating the pair’s merits as footballers, but it does, and will do again in the build-up to the latest battle in their never ending war, at Zurich Kongresshaus on January 7, where the winner of the 2012 FIFA Ballon d’Or will be announced.

I should stress at this point that this is not an attempt to construct an elaborate smokescreen. Ronaldo’s vanity and ostentatious persona are not the only reasons Messi has walked away with the last three Golden Balls. The fact that the Argentine is quite possibly the greatest player to have ever kicked a ball also has something to do with it.

But there is a sense that the gap between their actual abilities is considerably slimmer than the gap between their levels of public popularity. Within the context of this year’s Ballon d’Or, a good argument can be made for either man, and I won’t embark on any laborious statistical analysis. That’s been done elsewhere, ad nauseam.

My argument is simple – we don’t want to see a player as gifted as Ronaldo to become the Jimmy White to Messi’s Stephen Hendry. A perennial runner up, forced to watch glum faced as his nemesis hoists trophy after trophy into the air. Yes the Portuguese forward has won the Ballon d’Or before, back in 2008, but that was before his rivalry with Messi became what it is now.

It would be tragic if ‘CR7’ was to emerge from this storied period in football history, defined by two such supreme specimens bewitching us muggles with their wizardry, without anything to show for it. But that may well happen, because if he doesn’t win it this year, when will he?

He played an integral role in Madrid ending Messi and Barcelona’s stranglehold on the La Liga title. He almost single handedly took Portugal to the semi-finals of Euro 2012. He became the first player to score in six consecutive Clasicos. Even in the current campaign, a fairly wretched one by his club’s very high standards, he has managed to score 22 goals in all competitions.

Yes, Ronaldo is an egomaniac who’s spent the season telling us how ‘sad’ he is whilst living the sort of absurdly privileged lifestyle most of us would kill for. But if you can look at his facial expression during last year’s ceremony in Zurich, and not find your own face bathed in warm tears, then it’s my duty to tell you that you sir, are an android.

See the latest La Liga predictions and betting tips with

Have your say...
CR7 isn't even worthy of 2nd. I think, in my opinion, if it werent for Messi, Iniesta would be winning Ballon d'Or this year. He was the driving force behind Spain winning the European Championships, he is the second best player in the world. People argue that Ronaldo should win because of what he did with Portugal at Poland/Ukraine. Well if that is the basis of the argument, then Iniesta should win, Spain won the thing!
on the 7th January, 2013 at 3:13pm
Only the second to the last paragraph gives enough arguments as to why CR should deserve the Ballon D'Or.

Pathetically, the 4th & 3rd to and the last sentence of the piece attempts to argue, it seems, that he should win the Ballon D'Or just because he may fret and feel bad about losing the thing to Messi again.

Unfortunately for him & his supporters, should he lose again, the Ballon D'Or is simply given to the BEST FOOTBALLER, not the SECOND BEST. And 2012, I reckon was just Messi's year!
on the 7th January, 2013 at 10:35am
C R7 is d best player he deserve it, I really appreciate Messi talent as well. CR7 is d real man dat worth it.
on the 30th December, 2012 at 7:11pm
Hey, author. CR won the award before, alright? At least his fortune is better than Raul, Maldini, Xavi and Casillas. Let me just leave you with this: If your argument for his lack of balon dor award is his voters' disgust at his hairstyle, you severely underestimate public convention.
on the 25th December, 2012 at 7:18am
I think that Messi has been the better player during 2012 and definitely deserves the Ballon d'Or. Ronaldo has the second best player and it would be unfortunate if he does not get the second place because he deserves it.
What I do not want is for Ronaldo to be given the prize. I hope if he earns it, and be remembered as the undeniably best player in the world the year he won it.
on the 23rd December, 2012 at 9:55pm

Post new comment

Your email address is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
If you have your own website, enter its address here.
Maximum 500 characters.
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Enter the characters shown in the image.
Your responses will be moderated, and sometimes edited, by Football Espana before appearing on the site. Please keep your comments clean and try to keep them relevant to the blog above. We reserve the right to reject views that we deem unsuitable for publication.
Football Italia website